Part 3 of 10

A 17-year-old clerk faced a raised hammer beside her father’s shattered carousel—until the founder saw a second set of initials beneath one saddle. Who carved them?

39 min read · November 19, 2026

Earl did not look away.

“Where did you get the measurements for Georgia’s display?”

“From the original piece.”

“The original piece was in storage.”

“Then from observation.”

“Who measured it?”

“Our staff.”

“Who directed them?”

“Georgia.”

“Who approved the final pattern?”

“Georgia.”

Earl turned to Georgia.

“Is that true?”

Georgia looked at me. Her eyes were wet now, but she did not apologize.

“Yes.”

“There,” Carol said. “The matter is settled.”

Earl glanced at the display.

“Then why did Georgia remove this?”

Georgia swallowed.

“I didn’t.”

“Someone did.”

“I don’t know.”

“Your display is based on the original.”

“Yes.”

“Then why did you leave out the unfinished star?”

“I thought it was unfinished because it was damaged.”

“It was unfinished before the damage.”

“I didn’t know that.”

“But you copied the rest.”

Georgia opened her mouth.

No answer came.

Carol stepped beside her.

“Mr. Pemberton, this is becoming absurd. The star is a minor detail. We have a store to run, a contest to complete, and customers waiting to see the window.”

Earl looked toward the judges.

“Are you prepared to judge this display?”

The red-scarfed judge glanced at both carousels.

“We need clarification about the design process.”

“You have my clarification,” Carol said. “Georgia created the concept. The staff executed it. Lillian’s piece was never an approved entry.”

Earl’s hand closed around the horse.

“I have not given permission to continue.”

Carol’s voice became low.

“You don’t need to give permission. You appointed me to oversee the holiday displays.”

“I appointed you to protect the store.”

“I have done that.”

“No.”

The single word landed harder than the hammer.

Earl turned toward the employees.

“Put Georgia’s display on hold.”

No one moved.

Carol looked around the workshop.

“Do not touch the window.”

Earl’s cane tapped once against the floor.

“Put it on hold,” he repeated.

The young stock clerk near the curtain took one uncertain step toward the display.

Carol snapped, “Stop.”

The clerk stopped.

“With respect,” Carol told Earl, “you are undermining your own manager in front of the staff.”

“Perhaps I should have done so sooner.”

The color drained from her face.

She turned to the judges.

“The judging will continue under Georgia’s name.”

Earl’s eyes hardened.

“I said no.”

“And I said the window is ready.”

For a moment, they stood beneath the same Christmas lights, facing each other across the broken work.

Then Carol reached for the silver plaque beneath the window.

She lifted it toward the judges.

“Georgia Maddox, original designer.”

Her voice was bright again, controlled and professional.

“Please proceed.”

Earl looked at the plaque, then at the broken horse, then at me.

His eyes lingered on the brass paintbrush tucked behind my ear.

“Lillian,” he said.

Carol spun toward him.

“She is leaving.”

But Earl did not look at Carol.

“Have you ever seen this design before?”

I looked at the carousel in the window, at the smooth stars, the identical horses, and Georgia’s name.

“Yes,” I said.

“Where?”

“In my father’s workshop.”

Carol moved toward me.

Earl raised one hand.

She stopped.

“Did Raymond make the original?”

“Yes.”

“Did he design every part?”

“I thought he did.”

Earl’s face tightened at the word thought.

“My father never explained everything.”

“Why not?”

“Because Carol told me not to touch it.”

Carol’s voice sharpened.

“Mr. Pemberton, this is enough. She is attempting to create a dispute because she cannot accept that Georgia’s work is superior.”

Earl turned to her.

“Georgia’s work?”

The question hung in the air.

Earl faced the judges.

“I have made my position clear. This entry is under question.”

The red-scarfed judge nodded slowly.

“We will delay the final decision until the design can be verified.”

Carol’s hand tightened around the plaque.

“No.”

The judge looked at her.

“No?”

“You cannot delay it. The regional committee has a schedule.”

“Then the schedule can change.”

Carol glanced toward the shoppers, the employees, and the polished window meant to carry her daughter into a design apprenticeship.

“Georgia has worked hard,” she said.

Earl answered, “Has she?”

Georgia flinched.

Carol turned on me.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it? You wanted attention. You wanted everyone to feel sorry for you because your father died. You could not stand seeing Georgia succeed, so you brought this broken little toy into the store and made a scene.”

“I didn’t make the scene.”

“You attacked my display.”

“You attacked my father’s work.”

“He left it unfinished.”

The words stopped me.

Carol knew exactly where to strike.

“He left it unfinished,” she repeated. “He died before he could make it worth anything. And now you want to turn a half-built toy into a career.”

My throat burned. The brass brush trembled behind my ear.

Earl took one step toward her.

“Be careful.”

Carol laughed, but there was no humor in it.

“Why? Because Raymond was your friend? Because you carved your initials into a piece of wood sixty years ago? That does not make this girl qualified to design a department-store window.”

The room went quiet again.

Earl looked down at the broken horse, his finger resting over E.P.

When he lifted his head, something in him had changed.

Up next