Part 1 of 10

A 17-year-old clerk faced a raised hammer beside her father’s shattered carousel—until the founder saw a second set of initials beneath one saddle. Who carved them?

39 min read · November 19, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

The cane struck the locked office door with a crack that silenced the workshop.

Carol froze.

Earl Pemberton still held her wrist.

He was not a large man. At eighty-eight, he was thin beneath his dark overcoat, his shoulders curved with age. But his grip did not tremble.

“What did you just call it?” he asked.

Carol’s face had gone pale beneath her makeup.

“I said there was no need to concern yourself with—”

“The horse.”

His voice was quiet.

Earl lifted the broken piece beneath the overhead light. Sawdust clung to the blue paint. The saddle had split away from the body, exposing the tiny carving beneath it.

R.M.

E.P.

His thumb moved over the second set of initials.

“Who carved these?”

Carol pulled against his hand.

“Raymond, probably. He copied an old Pemberton ornament years ago.”

Earl released her. The sudden freedom made her stumble.

“An old ornament?” he repeated.

“Some of the older pieces have initials. It doesn’t prove anything.”

“E.P. stands for Earl Pemberton.”

A murmur moved through the workshop.

Carol smiled, but the expression looked fastened onto her face.

“Of course it does. Raymond copied your initials from one of the store’s old decorations.”

“Which one?”

“I don’t know.”

“You just said it was an old ornament.”

“I said he probably copied one.”

“Which one?”

Carol’s eyes sharpened.

“Mr. Pemberton, this is a contest presentation, not an interrogation.”

Earl turned the broken horse over.

“What year did Raymond copy it?”

Carol’s mouth opened.

No answer came.

Behind her, the polished carousel in Georgia’s window continued to turn, its motor clicking beneath the music.

The judges stood between the wreckage and the display.

Georgia looked at her mother.

Carol gave her the small nod she had used all week whenever Georgia forgot an approved phrase.

Georgia turned toward the judges.

“Our family has always admired the early Pemberton designs. My grandfather collected several of them.”

Carol’s eyes remained on Earl.

“My stepfather’s father owned a small wooden carousel with the same general shape. I believe my stepfather was inspired by it.”

I stared at her.

“Your stepfather’s father never owned one.”

Carol stepped between us.

“Lillian, enough.”

“Dad told me where every piece came from.”

“Your father told you stories because you were a child.”

“He made that carousel.”

“No one is denying he did some work on it.”

“Some work?”

Carol glanced at the judges.

“Raymond was a talented repairman. He was not a trained designer.”

Earl’s head lifted.

“Do not use that word about Raymond.”

“Mr. Pemberton—”

“You knew him for thirty years.”

“I knew him as an employee.”

“You knew him as a craftsman.”

“He was a craftsman,” Carol said quickly. “That does not make this girl a designer.”

I could feel the broken rail caught in my skirt, a splinter pressing my thigh whenever I moved.

Earl looked at it, then at me.

“Are you hurt?”

“No.”

Carol gave a short laugh.

“She threw herself into the display when I tried to prevent further damage. She has been very dramatic all morning.”

I had not thrown myself anywhere.

Carol had shoved me.

Priscilla stood near the worktable with both hands pressed against her paper snowflake. Her knuckles were white.

She had seen it.

Still, she said nothing.

Earl studied the broken horse.

“Lillian, did you carve these initials?”

“No.”

“Did your father?”

“I don’t know.”

Carol snatched the answer from the air.

“Of course he did. Raymond carved all sorts of things. He was fond of hiding little jokes in his work.”

Earl looked at her.

“You seem certain now.”

“I’m certain this piece has nothing to do with the contest.”

“Then why did you take it?”

“I took it because it belongs with the display.”

“Which display?”

“Georgia’s.”

“Why?”

“It matches the design.”

I looked toward the window.

The imitation carousel glittered beneath the lights. Its roof was taller than my father’s, its railings smooth and perfectly painted. The horses had been molded from the same pattern, their faces blank and identical.

“Then put the horse beside it,” Earl said.

“There is no reason to interrupt the judging.”

“I asked you to put it beside the window.”

The judge with the red scarf stepped forward.

“I think that would be reasonable.”

Carol turned toward her.

“With respect, this is my department. I have prepared this presentation for six weeks.”

“And Mr. Pemberton is the founder of the store,” the judge replied.

For a second, Carol looked ready to refuse. Then she reached for the tray.

Earl moved first. He took the broken horse from the pile and carried it toward the display himself.

His cane tapped across the tile.

I followed without thinking.

Carol caught my arm.

“You are not going anywhere.”

Her fingers dug into the same wrist Earl had held.

“Let go.”

“You have caused enough disruption.”

“Earl asked to see the horse.”

“He did not ask you to follow him.”

“He asked me who carved the initials.”

“And you said you didn’t know. Then you have no further role.”

She turned toward the employees.

“Priscilla, escort Lillian out of the workshop.”

Up next